The Yankees decided to go the frugal route in filling the position of first base. They signed Doug Mientkiewicz to platoon with either Andy Phillips or Rule 5 Draft Pick Josh Phelps. The 32 year old lefty swinging Doug Mientkiewicz is one of the best defensive first basemen in baseball. He should save Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez some of the throwing errors they made last season. He only made 3 errors in 724.2 innings last season for the Royals. He also hit a solid .283 with a .770 OPS last season. Look for Mientkiewicz to keep his batting average in the .270-280 range and to hit around 10 homers as he should get a lot of good pitches to hit in this line up.
30 year old, home grown Andy Phillips will get a chance to earn a platoon job with Mientkiewicz in Spring Training but it won’t be easy as he’ll have to show improvement in a lot of areas to go north with the Yanks when camp breaks. Phillips hit only .240 with a .675 OPS and those are poor numbers for a first baseman. He did show some power last season as he hit 7 homers and knocked in 29 runs in 246 at bats. Phillips needs to work on his defense at first base as he made 7 errors in only 533 innings and that’s too many for a first baseman.
The Yankees made a good selection in the Rule 5 Draft when they selected the 29 year old Josh Phelps off the roster of the enemy Baltimore Orioles’ roster. Phelps had a solid season in AAA last year as he hit .308 with a .903 OPS and hit 24 homers and knocked in 90 runs. He has big-time power and has proved it in the majors. He has played in 352 games in the majors and has averaged a homer every 21.1 at bats and an RBI every 5.67 at bats. Project those numbers out over a season and that’s big production. He has a career batting average of .268 with a .809 OPS. I’m betting that he will beat out Phillips for the job.
Also, keep an eye on 24 year old rookie Juan Miranda. The Yankees really like his left-handed stick. He will more than likely start the year in the minors. But if the first basemen on the Yanks struggle he could get a call at some point in the year.